There are so many words for “said”: explained, shouted,
yelled, whispered, complained, announced…you get the picture. In some of the
work I critique, sentences go something like this:
‘Hello!’ yelled Jane.
‘It’s nice to see you,’ announced Mary.
‘What a fine day,’ John commented.
Right. It sounds terrible – not just because of the
incredibly lame names I just used, but mostly because of the words for “said” I
used. There is nothing wrong with the
word said. Having so many different words for said draws even more
attention than using it too much.
By comparison, below is an excerpt of my WIP.
‘Sure is,’ Chris says as he appears from below. ‘Best place in the
school.’
‘Best place in Rain,’ Thea corrects him. ‘Is that what
you were named after, Cloud?’
‘I don’t know,’ I
say. ‘Robert – my dad – was going to tell me, but he got distracted.’
‘You call your
dad Robert?’ says Thea. ‘That’s a bit strange. Actually, come to think of it,
how did you get here in the first place? To the school and whatever?’
‘Long story,’ I
say, because it is.
‘We’ve got heaps
of time,’ Thea says. ‘Like, bundles and bundles of it.’
And the bell
rings.
‘Maybe not,’ Thea
says.
Notice that even though I use “say” or “says” most of the
time, it still sounds natural. Now, I probably should have used another example
rather than mine, but you still get it…I hope.
The word said is not your enemy. Love it. Treat it with
respect. Don’t use it every single time, but using it for most dialogue is fine…good
even.
Other editors or authors might tell you not to use “laughed”
as a substitute for said. But in that case I actually disagree, because I think
it works. You might not be able to laugh while talking, but it conveys the
image of someone laughing before or after. Which is a good thing. I would still
tend to stay away from unrealistic “said” words most of the time.
Instead perhaps use them as action tags. “That’s hilarious,”
he said, laughing. See? It works just as well.
In doubt about which word to use? Said. Said is your friend.
One final note: please don’t use “ejaculated.” Unless you’re
trying to make people laugh.
PS: In my excerpt above, her name isn’t really Cloud. Just
if you were wondering.
No comments:
Post a Comment